A Desultory Writer's Journey

Pulsating in my noggin now is this stock but stimulating statement from Constance Nash and Virginia Oakey's Screenwriter's Handbook: "Writers must write and write and write. Then rewrite and rewrite. A mere idea or concept is not enough to show your seriousness about writing or to provide proof of your talent." This, reason the authors, is what all the screenwriters interviewed for the book (including William Goldman [Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, All the President's Men], Ernest Lehman [North by Northwest, Sweet Smell of Success, The Sound of Music], and Gene Wilder [Young Frankenstein]) "all agree upon, without exception." 

Which spurs reflection on my on-again-off-again approach to writing that has wavered my status between bold and blocked, sparked and sporadic, famous and forgotten. This may have originated in my simultaneously auspicious and awkward start as a writer: "In spite of Todd's great talent for writing, he has trouble responding to an assigned or suggested topic, and often simply refuses to try." That third-grade report wasn't completely accurate, though. Only occasionally was I recalcitrant to put pencil to paper. Otherwise I usually took stabs at in-class assignments, only to blush at what had grown from my graphite and squirrel it into my desk, or crumple it up and throw it away. 

Nor did I show "great talent." The "Magic Land" books I scribbled at home and read aloud to the class were mere slapdash flapdoodle on the whims, daydreams and fantasies of my wild-child imagination's momentary impulses, with no logical story development, no moral message, no originality, and ninety percent plagiarism. This is how I became "copy king," abdicating my personal creativity to claim for my own my wonderment with the written wonderworlds of Roald Dahl, Norton Juster, comic-book creators and Sesame Street scribes – perhaps as a way of acting out my envy of those authors for their rich imagination, and my feeling that I would never be able to write that well, even though I was just a kid who was yet to develop his abilities. (My copycatting was usually rewarded with impunity, miraculously – and unfortunately.)

As my plagiarism phase waned, my writing sharpened, to the point of inflating my ego. It was abruptly punctured in college as I got to know two students who could miraculously write most of their papers in one draft, receive High Honors on virtually every one, and graduate summa cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa with Highest Honors in their majors, to the point where their names became synonymous with "brilliant" and "genius" on campus. Conversely, my C-plus on my one-draft paper made it clear to me what I needed to pursue to hope for genius: "one percent inspiration and ninety-nine percent perspiration," in Thomas Edison's words.

Another ego-deflator for me was Advanced Composition, both for the common sense the professor gave me – "Writers write" and "Write, write, write!" – and for the feedback I got when I did write. The poems and stories I wrote for that course were largely criticized for banality, hyperbole, implausibility, and predictability. Ever on the defensive, I rebuffed all the criticism, which provoked more common-sense comments: "So what was your point of involving us in a story?" and "If you're writing for yourself, that's one thing, but if you're writing for others..." 

Still defensive, I submitted two stories and two poems from that class to the college's literary journal. None were accepted; most were marked "OUT," one "OVERWRITTEN." But the journal editor enriched his rebuffs with feedback designed to "help you improve," in his words, with critiques that paralleled those my class gave me, but were more thoughtful: "Do people really talk like that?"

That became a pervading theme of a screenwriting professor's unrelenting criticism of my work the following year – "Dialogue is skimpy. Flesh it out. Make it real. Make it believable" – but with a key takeaway that still holds force for me today: "Writing is rewriting." Further signs of my deficit of true cinematic talent – culminating in a playwright's refusal to pay me my full fee due to her dissatisfaction with how I rendered her play in screenplay form – eventually dissuaded me from my Hollywood ambitions. 

But journalism opportunities knocked. Following a well-received string of Somerville News cover stories, I came on board at The TAB Newspapers (now WickedLocal), only to become so buried in paper with increased typing and Service Directory advertorial writing duties that my story output was infrequent – and at times I actually preferred those simpler, more routine tasks to the far more complex, probing, analyzing, conclusion-drawing, restructuring and rewriting process of composing a news story. Hence my performance review included: "Todd takes on an adequate load but doesn't push himself." Yes, here was a perspiration shortfall. That changed a bit when I was assigned to write home-of-the-week features for various publications, some on the cover of Boston Homes, always well received by the brokers of the properties I wrote about. That ended due to budget cuts, followed by my full layoff.

About that time I started an architecture commentary blog, ArchiTalk, which varied from frequent to fleeting, but which I often marvel at when I reread (and sometimes rewrite) my posts, wondering, not Gene Wilder's frequent plaint, "What did I write that for?" but "Who wrote that for me?" This is probably due to my commitment to rewriting them before I posted them, and sometimes after that. As Wilder once said, in reiteration of my takeaway from my screenwriting professor, There isn't really any writing. There is only rewriting." (Those are the main reasons why I write and rewrite ArchiTalk with the near-daily frequency that Nash & Oakey urged: the realization that someone who could write like that should do it more often.)

I don't know whether it was my architecture blog, my home-of-the-week features, my witty posts on South Boston real estate trends for a local Realtor's blog, or my "Executive Domains" home profiles for the Boston Business Journal that knocked me the opportunity of a lifetime: to write for The Boston Globe. Jumping at this chance, I penned a feature for the paper's Sunday real estate section on the initiative to house homeless veterans spearheaded by then Boston Mayor Marty Walsh (who I interviewed for the story). "Good read," was the editor's reaction.

Hope.

Then she assigned me to write an online profile on a new housing development in Chinatown. She rewrote virtually all of it, and my mention to her of an affordable housing advocate's demand to mention the development's affordability component provoked the following reaction: "I am pulling the article."

Trouble.

Though she didn't pull the article, she never assigned me another, and I had to pitch story proposals to her, one of which she accepted: the restoration of historic homes that had been converted to condominiums or other uses back to their original single-family states, including the former Back Bay headquarters of the Church of Scientology. After I submitted the story, she called its fact-checking process "brutal." My subsequent pitches were met with variations on the "I'm going to pass" theme, followed by an expression of doubt about wanting to work with me again because my reporting "wasn't thorough."

More trouble.

Yet she gave me a second chance and let me write a feature on 3D printed houses as a panacea to the housing affordability crisis, which she seemed happier with, but noted that the fact-check yielded "several changes," and responded to my subsequent story pitches with another "I'm going to pass." With that I put myself on a hiatus for writing for the Globe, but when I pitched stories to her again a few years later, I never even heard back from her, as if she had all the good writers she needed and was done with me, or at least I wasn't on her priority list. Such are the consequences of not measuring up to the high standards of nationally renowned publications like the Globe.

Yet for the first time I didn't blame certain authors for being "exceptions" to Nash & Oakey's rule-of-thumb for writers. I didn't blame Harper Lee for not writing another novel after all the attention lavished on her for To Kill a Mockingbird, which extended to a Pulitzer Prize and the Presidential Medal of Freedom, until she was prodded into publishing an early draft of it as Go Set a Watchman shortly before her death. Her main reasons for stopping her writing were that she couldn't handle all the publicity and loss of privacy that To Kill a Mockingbird had brought her, and she feared that any subsequent novels she wrote would not measure up, as the unfavorable reviews of Go Set a Watchman suggested. Nor did I blame Margaret Mitchell for taking a break from the toils of Lost Leysen and Gone with the Wind and the latter's triumph as a classic in book and movie form (though who knows what might have transpired had she not been killed by a drunk driver while crossing the street). 

However, I always had a problem with J.D. Salinger ceasing publication of his writings after his novella "Hapworth 16, 1924" took up more than half an issue of The New Yorker in 1965 and The Catcher in the Rye beame a multigenerational cult classic beyond belief for a first novel. I've always looked forward to the further adventures of Holden Caulfield, the Glass family, and the other colorful characters Salinger conjured up in the reclusive privacy of his Cornish, New Hampshire home over 45 years. ("He just writes and keeps it there," his agent said in a 1980 New York Times piece, in which Salinger himself said, "I'm just trying to protect myself and my work.") At least I'm glad he found peace with himself through writing for the sake of writing, and for his own enjoyment, without dealing with the hassles of publishing and bad reviews. Yet writing is as good as dead if not read by others, which is why I release my writings to the public in blog form, and even post rewrites of them.

I also wince at the perfectionism that delayed Ralph Ellison's second novel, Juneteenth, from publication until after he became a truly "invisible man." 
But let's face it – few of us can be literary one-hit wonders like Lee, Mitchell, Salinger and Ellison, or academic one-draft wonders like my precocious college mates (who, incidentally, are now a Professor of English at Auburn University in Alabama and a Professor of Religion at Whitman College in Walla Walla, Washington). For they are the exceptions that prove Nash and Oakey's rules about frequent writing and rewriting, which I follow religiously now – and must follow, lest they forget about me again.

Especially in light of my painfully embarrassing termination from a Proposal Writer position at an architecture firm a year ago, with such performance-review comments as "Fails to follow instructions," "Is more interested in writing for the sake of writing than writing to make a statement," and especially "I don't trust him."

Still more trouble.

The trouble is, I'm still sensitive to criticism and rejection. (Perhaps Salinger was.) Other people's failure to appreciate what I have to offer is the most hurtful thing. It makes me feel like an "invisible man," putting his work out there but reaping no rewards for it, as if I didn't exist. I hope that my daily writing will help me to overcome this sensitivity, by enabling me not only to continually improve, tweak and polish my writing, but also to continually remind myself that I'm a writer (as this blog's title affirms), and don't see myself as anything else (except maybe an editor).

Please wish me luck. Thank you.

P.S. This new blog, "The Writer," is an outgrowth of my revisitation (and rewriting) of some essays I wrote in a GrubStreet course on "The Personal Essay," taught by Jennifer Crystal eight years ago. I was ambivalent about it at the time, mainly because I lacked the cold reading skills necessary to give students feedback on their work, a curse of my Asperger syndrome. But a second look at my essays really impressed me. So I launched this blog as a way to showcase my writing on subjects other than architecture – that is, to show how versatile I could be as a writer.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Yesterday (the back-to-school essay I wish I'd written at the start of ninth grade)

Johnny, I Hardly Knew Ye